1. Reflections toward e-learning

 

1. Strongly Disagree

2. Disagree

3. Neutral

4. Agree

5. Strongly Agree

Response Total

Sucess in e-learning depends on the way the material is presented.

4% (1)

0% (0)

17% (4)

30% (7)

48% (11)

23

E-learninig should be an enjoyable experience.

0% (0)

0% (0)

0% (0)

32% (7)

68% (15)

22

E learning environments are not as reputable as traditional learning environments.

24% (5)

24% (5)

19% (4)

33% (7)

0% (0)

21

Online learning cannot ensure quality since there is no f2f interaction

55% (12)

32% (7)

5% (1)

0% (0)

9% (2)

22

E learning is not suitable for formal education

73% (16)

18% (4)

5% (1)

0% (0)

5% (1)

22

Digital divide is a serious problem for developed countries

0% (0)

18% (4)

18% (4)

27% (6)

36% (8)

22

Providing computers to the community is the key to success in e-learning

0% (0)

32% (7)

36% (8)

27% (6)

5% (1)

22

E-learning should be considered as a global issue rather than a local one

0% (0)

9% (2)

23% (5)

55% (12)

14% (3)

22

There should be a preparation process for participants to start their e learning experience

0% (0)

10% (2)

5% (1)

33% (7)

52% (11)

21

It is not possible to assess students' progress in an e learning environment since there is no f2f meetings

81% (17)

10% (2)

5% (1)

0% (0)

5% (1)

21

we need alternative testing methods for e learning environments to replace traditional ones

5% (1)

0% (0)

10% (2)

52% (11)

33% (7)

21

The use of CMC tools adds quality to e-learning

0% (0)

0% (0)

0% (0)

19% (4)

81% (17)

21

Total Respondents  

23

 

 

2. Which one would you prefer to attend: a traditional institution or an online one if you had both options?

 

 

Response Percent

Response Total

 

Traditional

23.8%

5

 

Online

66.7%

14

 

 

Why?

90.5%

19

Total Respondents  

21

(skipped this question)  

2

 

 

 

Which one would you prefer to attend: a traditional institution or an online one if you had both options?

 

1.

I feel there are still aspects of f2f interaction that CMC captures either badly or not at all.

2.

an education delivered online would be more convenient in my specific circumstances

3.

to go through the experience myself

4.

because I have had experience with e-learning

5.

I'd prefer a combination of both

6.

I have found much more interaction and more learning.

7.

- More flexible - Saves time - easy to handle - Avoid hesitation among learners and support the autonomy in learning

8.

Provided class-facilitator ratios are reasonable, and facilitator and participants are active in responding to Ss, there can be more intimacy and more access to the thoughts and experiences of the learning community, and potentially access to the experts around the world. This is highly empowering. Unfortunately, in some traditional institutions,instructor's use of datashow (e.g. powerpoint) is low in content depth and interaction, and very difficult for those with hearing and visual disabilities to follow, while e-learning can be tailored to individual needs and has the potential for older users, and disabled to continue their education from a convenient place.

9.

This question is too general, as sometimes we need to be in a traditional institution, depending on what we want to learn.However, I prefer to attend one which provides both.

10.

Ultimately f2f interaction with both professor and classmates facilitates learning. While many subjects can be covered in an electronic envirionment, not all subjects fare equally. At some point in any degree program, I would expect some course require f2f/classroom interaction, depending upon the subject matter.

11.

Convenience of time and place. I can study anywhere online.

12.

in an online environment, I would probably have to meet with other people from abroad, which in an enriching way of sharing our cultures - and besides, I feel less embarrased to participate that in many face to face situations where I will sometimes feel anxiety to speak up before that golden moment has passed .I often prefer to write when it comes to more complex meanings, and I can have all my notges and books ready at hand when I work from home. it is also an advantage that I can participate in asynch discussions at times that fit me . But, in some cases, when ever geographically possible, a mixed mode style would be perfect, with a few meetings f2f, and networing ojnline in between

13.

After my degree yes. Not before. Because I have more posibilities to choose. But also It depends on what.

14.

To get away from home. Otherwise, I would like to attend an online institution. At the same time, I know that I am not a good online student (having taken both online and traditional courses) - I like to procrastinate to much. After all, that is why my motto is "Never do today what you can put off until tomorrow."

15.

Online is what I've sought out lately

16.

I can study at my own pace and time.

17.

As an adult I have many other responsibilities and calls on my time. It is therefore easier to 'attend' online learning. However it might depend on the subject! I'd rather learn to ride a bike in a f2f setting.

18.

It depends on the kind of coursework I would be taking and the time of day a course was offered. However, in learning to use multimedia, I prefer a f2f course if it is available.

19.

Assuming that there are no educational institutions that offer high quality course/s or degree that you would like to take in your country, online learning can make this possible.

 

 

 

3. How would you rate WIA in terms of quality?

 

 

Response Percent

Response Total

 

 

Completely Satisfactory

61.9%

13

 

 

Satisfactory

38.1%

8

 

 

Just Enough

0%

0

 

 

Unsatisfactory

0%

0

 

 

Completely Unsatisfactory

0%

0

Total Respondents  

21

(skipped this question)  

2

 

 

Please list 5 features that you think are essential for quality on-line learning.

 

1.

1. A sense of adventure on the part of participants. 2. A willingness to put the learners' varied agendas ahead of the moderators. 3. Some level of administrative support.

2.

adequate student support appropriate assessment opportunities for collaborative student work flexible and open course structure good quality study guide and resources

3.

1. Dedicated e-support 2. Reputable outcome 3. Serious content 4. Effective instruction 5. Friendly online community

4.

*good preparation of both facilitators and students *being a good communicator *having computer literacy *knowing about possible problems and being ready to solve them *being a WIA member before plunging into the experience ...(or part of any other CoP...)

5.

Materials strong interaction between tutors, students, experts... Appropiated software in order students from everywhere could view the material without downloading problems

6.

good facilitation good computer/Internet skills self-motivation purpose for learning sense of community

7.

well-defined objectives well laid-out and motivating syllabus dynamic coordinator/facilitator assessment rubrics intense interactivity and collaboration

8.

- Good preparation - Consideration of all facilitites and variety among learners - Encourage all memebers to participate in different flexible ways - Show learners the outcomes of their contribution to an e-learning course

9.

Clear navigation Availability of encouraging help and support Clear constructive specific feedback to and from learners asap after the learning event Clear framework for activities Flexibility to meed learners' needs e.g. disabilities, time zones, synchronous and asynchronous modes, learning styles and different language backgrounds

10.

1.Content-based learning. 2.Motivating objectives of Activities/Projects. 3.Cooperative-learning. 4.Collaborative-learning. 5.The role of moderation/moderator must be clear to all participants. 6.Utilization of available CMC tools as means of Language Learning and practice. 7.Teacher/moderator's teaching methods and approches should be centered on the utilization of the whole on-line learning process/experience as a mean to create independent and life learners, implicitly.

11.

1. Responsible e-mailing procedures: (i.e., mail should be used in the same way one would use verbal comments in the classroom). Extraneous information needs to be kept to a minimum (to prevent overflowing e-mailboxes) and no single student should monopolize the forum. 2. CMC interaction: for both class instruction and peer support/interaction. 3. Subject matter: material that is condusive to online delivery. 4. Instructor availability: teachers need to make themselves available to students regularly - as they would in f2f - with scheduled online office hours. 6. Cross-platform software and supplemental materials so students of many economic levels can participate equally. 5. T1 or cable internet access: anything less requires too much of a time investment.

12.

1. Good references to resources, esp. online. 2. Smart use of technology, e.g., summarizing chat logs on a Webpage with an internally linked Index. 3. Willing participants, e.g. a community. You can't get much out of e-learning if others are not contributing--it's like a one-sided conversation (also known as "lecture"). 4. A good CMC site, one that allows sharing of links, uploading of text and html files, stable hookup to chat, even use of "higher level" technologies, such as Webcam (and it would be nice if it were free or nearly free. 5. A thinking moderator, one who can plan a succession of lessons or inspire others to get involved in the planning process; one who can stay out of the way when things are going well, and give a nudge to get things back on track. Luckily, WIA has all of the above!!

13.

1. to feel comfortable with the people you meet 2. to be ready for the unexpected 3. to have access to the relevant tools, know where to get help when needed and time for practising with my peers 4. to document ongoing knowledge building 5. to get inspired tor reflective teamworking and critical thinking

14.

1. E-moderator. 2. Interface. 3. Motivation. 4. Knowledge on IT (student) 5. Interactivity.

15.

1. Responsibility 2. Ability to stick to a topic and see it though no matter how bored you are. 3. Interest in the topic.

16.

knowledgeable practitioners appropriate learning algorithms appropriate software interfaces emphasis on community adequate bandwidth and network infrastructure

17.

-interaction and collaboration -social scaffolding -reflection -appropriate moderation -alternative assessment procedures

18.

1. Frequent intervention by tutors or moderators. This shows there is life at the other end of the line. 2. Opportunities to discuss course content frequently with fellow students. 3. A stable technical environment. One must have confidence that one's essays are not going to disappear in a server error. 4. Endorsement by respected and relevant organisations such as a university or other awarding body. 5. Top quality content.

19.

1. High interaction 2. Negotiated projects 3. Awareness of e-learning's problems 4. Support (and not just lip service) from institutions. 4. Personnel dedicated to online learning (and not as a side project)

20.

1 motivation 2 personal e-contact between the teacher and the students 3 group activities that necessitate students working together and getting to know others in the class 4 a window of time to complete assignments--at least a week, sometimes longer, so that students who work fulltime can find time to complete the assignment 5 feedback from the professor on how well the student is progressing

21.

useful and relevant materials aside from the moderator/teacher's tutelage, the human factor (helpful, down-to-earth, etc) also counts instant response from teachers or classmates/colleagues sense of community-or belonging

 

Back to Top


a href="http://dygonza.esmartweb.com/evonline2003/week6/w6p2.htm">Back to Main Page